GTA 6 has one of the highest critic scores Metacritic has ever recorded, but its user score tells a very different story. Since user reviews opened after the November 19 launch, the score has bounced between roughly 4.9 and 5.4 out of 10. This post looks only at that user number: where it came from, what players are saying, and what can and can’t be proven about it so far.
How the user score moved
Metacritic held back user reviews for a while after the release date, then opened them. Early reports had the score at 5.2/10 with about 13,192 ratings. Tech4Gamers reported 4.9/10 from more than 4,900 reviews on November 21. Later coverage from Men’s Journal put it at 5.1 from almost 10,000 reviews, and a more recent Metacritic snapshot showed 5.4 from more than 31,000 ratings. Because these numbers were taken at different times, the honest read is a range, not a single fixed score.
Why the score is so low
The explanation you’ll hear most is review bombing. Rockstar fans argue that many low scores come from people who don’t own the game on PS5 or Xbox, and that the pattern looks coordinated. Mezha points to one signal: a large number of zero scores, which is what you’d expect if people are piling on rather than reviewing the game.
Two things keep that argument from being the whole story. First, ownership isn’t shown on Metacritic, so nobody can check who wrote what. Second, many of the low scores come with specific complaints, and those complaints are what players keep repeating.
What players are actually complaining about
- Frame rate. GTA 6 runs at 30 FPS on PS5, PS5 Pro and Xbox Series X|S, as we covered before launch. Mezha reports that on PS5 Pro the visuals run at 30 fps or below. Some reviewers give very low scores based on the frame rate alone, which is harsher than most critics were.
- Pacing and realism. Men’s Journal reports complaints about the game’s realism-first approach, especially the early hours, where players can go grocery shopping and buy gifts for Lucia. Players who expected a faster, more arcade-style GTA have said they didn’t get one.
- The story focus. Tech4Gamers reports that some reviews focus on the Jason and Lucia relationship, and some cite DEI as a reason for a low score. These are opinions about content, not technical problems, and they are the most divisive part of the user reviews.
Some reviews also go as low as 1/10 or 2/10, which Tech4Gamers argues are scores usually reserved for broken games. Whether or not a reviewer’s score is fair, the score is driven by a mix of real complaints and a loud group of low-score ratings.
Why it matters
Metacritic’s user score is a public signal, and it currently sits far below the critic score. Tech4Gamers says the gap is now the widest of any game on the site. That doesn’t prove the critics or the players are wrong. It means two groups who played the same game came away with very different views of it.
Metacritic has a known review-bombing problem, and Tech4Gamers notes the platform has not found a workable fix. Men’s Journal says it remains to be seen whether Metacritic removes any of the less constructive scores.
What to watch next
Three things will show whether this is a launch-week spike or a lasting verdict. First, whether the score settles as the rating count keeps growing. Second, whether Metacritic acts on the zero-score pattern. Third, whether Rockstar changes anything that players are complaining about, especially performance on PS5 Pro. Until then, the user score is best read as a snapshot of a loud debate, not a final grade.
Never miss a drop.
Release dates, leaks, reviews & patch notes — the biggest gaming news, straight to your inbox.
- ⚡ Daily headlines
- 📅 Release radar
- 🔒 Zero spam
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.

Join the discussion